Employee listening
Stay interviews and exit interviews answer different questions.
A stay interview asks a current employee about the experience they want to preserve or improve. An exit interview asks a departing employee to reflect on their decision and the work they are leaving. A people team can use both, provided it keeps the timing, participant group and purpose visible. This guide gives you a decision method and a worksheet for comparing themes.
Choose the conversation for the decision you need to make
Use a stay interview when you want to discuss a current employee’s experience and identify a change or support request they would find useful. Use an exit interview when someone is leaving and you want to understand their account of the decision, the role and the handover. NHS Employers’ retention guidance describes both as routes for learning from staff experience.
Write down the decision before selecting a method. A manager considering how to support an employee now needs a current conversation. A people team reviewing how a role is experienced over time may need several complementary sources and a clearly defined review period.
Compare the timing and the action you can offer
In a stay interview, the work relationship continues. Ask what is helping, what needs attention and which action to explore first. Close with a current owner and a follow-up date. The manager needs enough authority and support to act on whatever commitment they accept.
In an exit interview, the employee has decided to leave. Ask which experiences shaped that decision, when those experiences occurred and what the organization should understand. Give the person room to describe several factors. Keep practical departure arrangements and the listening purpose clear so the employee knows which questions concern their handover and which seek feedback.
Adapt the question while keeping the theme recognizable
For a development theme, a stay question could be, “What would you like more opportunity to learn or do, and what would help you start?” An exit question could be, “How did the development opportunities available here relate to what you wanted next?” Both can inform a review of development support, but the employee is answering from a different position.
Use the same approach for scheduling. Ask a current employee about a recent change they would like improved. Ask a departing employee which work-pattern experiences mattered to their decision and when they happened. Keep the actual wording with the notes so later reviewers can interpret the answer.
Offer a conversation people can use
Explain who will conduct the interview, who can access the notes and how the feedback may inform action. Tell the person how to request another appropriate contact. A direct manager may be well placed to arrange current support, while another authorized interviewer may help someone discuss a difficult experience involving that relationship.
Share the topics beforehand and allow the person to decline a question. NIH’s stay interview guide recommends keeping stay conversations separate from formal performance discussions. Decide the equivalent practical boundaries for your exit process. Give each interviewer a clear route for concerns that require established HR handling.
Combine themes without collapsing the groups
Create a review grid with separate columns for current employees and leavers. Add the group definition, review period, invitations, participation and question wording. Record which accounts describe a direct experience and which report an interpretation. Check for voices missing from either route.
Someone who remained may have obtained a useful work arrangement. Someone who left may have asked for a similar arrangement at a different time or under different conditions. Those accounts can help identify what to examine. They do not establish how every employee experienced the process. Look for a relevant process record and a counterexample before deciding what a shared theme means.
Try the comparison on a fictional development issue
Imagine current employees ask how to qualify for project assignments. Departing employees describe uncertainty about how those assignments were allocated. The people team reviews the two sets of accounts separately, including the period and roles represented. It then checks the published criteria and the actual route used to submit requests.
A useful next action could be to clarify the request and decision process and have the responsible team test it on a new assignment cycle. The team can tell current employees how to use it and offer a realistic update on the review. The example illustrates a decision path and contains no claim about the effect on retention.
Use other sources when the question needs them
Stay and exit interviews are selected accounts from different moments in an employment relationship. They may leave out people who did not take part or experiences no one chose to discuss. Consider existing employee listening, onboarding feedback and approved workforce records where they help answer the defined question.
CIPD’s employee voice guidance describes the value of complementary channels. Use the source suited to the detail you need, and keep access and purpose clear. For turnover reporting, retain the organization’s definitions and denominators. A count of interview themes and a departure rate describe different aspects of the review.
Make two action records and one organizational review
Keep current individual commitments with the owner who accepted them. Keep departure-related actions with the appropriate offboarding owner. For an organizational theme, record the supporting accounts, uncertainty, proposed response and process owner in a separate review entry.
Set a point to check delivery and hear from the people affected by the change. If the revised assignment process was published, ask whether employees could find it and submit a request, then check the route worked as described. Report what changed and what is still uncertain. That provides a practical way to combine the learning while honoring the different purposes of the conversations.
Talk to Lontra HR
Bring one real HR question.
See how a first campaign could work for your team.